Federal Judge Rules Vaccine Mandate at Louisiana College ‘Violates Religious Liberty’

Shared with permission from Think Americana

A federal judge ruled against the vaccine mandate at a Louisiana medical school on the grounds that it violates religious liberty rights under the Louisiana Constitution. The judge also issued a temporary restraining order against the school.

Edward Via College of Osteopathic Medicine (VCOM) attempted to mandate their students get the COVID-19 vaccine. However, U.S. District Judge Terry Doughty struck it down after students Lynn Magliulo, Matthew Shea Willis, and Kirsten Willis Hall revealed the school’s policy and noted how it infringed on their freedom of religion.

On June 30, 2021, VCOM sent out an email to students notifying them that the school was requiring all students to receive a full coronavirus vaccination to enroll in fall 2021 classes. The email also said religious and medical exemptions, which the college limited, would be heard on an individual basis. However, VCOM later contradicted itself by saying it would not recognize religious or medical exemptions, according to court documents.

The three students dissented and requested exemptions based on “deeply held religious beliefs.” According to the temporary restraining order, the students objected to the vaccine because they believed them to be “devised from aborted fetal tissues, violating their religious beliefs.” They also dissented because the vaccine is approved for emergency use only “and is therefore experimental.”

However, all of their exemptions were denied. That is when the students decided to take action.

After it became clear the students were pursuing legal action against the school, VCOM changed its exemption policy three times, approved the students’ religious exemptions “for the current time,” and ultimately created what Judge Doughty found to be burdensome restrictions that would interfere with the students’ ability to graduate.

One of the school’s excessive restrictions included barring unvaccinated students from participating in Standardized Patient Examinations and Early Clinical Experiences “which are required to advance or graduate,” according to court documents.


Judge Doughty said the “threat to religious freedom was imminent” when referring to the students’ case, and he said the “potential harm of a constitutional violation, ability to complete their education, ethics charges, and possible expulsion outweighs VCOM’s interest.”

He further noted that restrictions on students’ ability to dissent from the mandate which keeps them from being able to graduate “defeats the purpose of having the right of dissent.”

Louisiana law does not provide a method for institutions to restrict dissent. VCOM would be authorized to exclude unvaccinated students until the end of the disease incubation period or until they present evidence of vaccination. However, that mechanism requires a recommendation from the Louisiana Office of Public Health, which the school does not have.

“Therefore, under Louisiana law, students at VCOM are not subject to VCOM’s mandatory vaccine requirements if the student provides a written statement from a physician that the procedure is contraindicated for medical reason or presents a written dissent from a student or student’s guardian,” Doughty ruled.

More on the story at Breitbart News 

Trending Political News

Click Here to Get Your FREE "Don't Blame Me" Mug

don't blame me mug

Sen. Cruz: 'Pelosi is Drunk on Power' - Probably Vodka Too

On Thursday, Senator Ted Cruz slammed House Speaker Nancy Pelosi on the Senate floor, declaring that she is drunk on power with her new mask mandates. Power isn't the only thing she is drunk on...I'd say there is some vodka in the mix too.

“Power tends to corrupt, and absolute power corrupts, absolutely. Great men are almost exclusively bad men, even where they exercise influence and not authority,” Cruz said, pulling from a series of letters to Bishop Craig from Lord Acton. He added that “those words were true in 1887, and they’re true today.”

Continue reading…

WATCH: Staffer Passes Biden a Note to Wipe His Chin

Joe Biden. Bless his heart. How he has wormed his way into the Oval Office when he should be in a nursing home is beyond me. Yet here we are.

Today, Biden sat in front of cameras for what appears to be a wildfire briefing. Suddenly a staffer comes into view and slides a piece of paper to Biden. He reads it, and then promptly wipes his chin. However, he then holds the note where the camera can see it at different points. Once, it even faces the camera directly.

Continue reading…

Freaky Friday: Jamie Lee Curtis Praises Son for Turning into Daughter

Actress Jamie Lee Curtis, well known for her roles in many films including Freaky Friday and Halloween, is praising her son's decision to become her "daughter."

Curtis told AARP Magazine that she and her husband (Christopher Guest) have "watched in wonder and pride as our son became our daughter Ruby.” Ruby, formerly known as Thomas, is the child in question.

Continue reading…

Justice Dept Orders IRS to Hand Trump's Tax Returns Over to Congress

Throughout former President Donald Trump's entire presidency, it was an ongoing issue with Democrats that they did not have Trump's tax returns. Unlike other recent presidents, he did not disclose that information.

However, on Friday, the U.S. Justice Department ordered the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) to hand Trump's tax returns over to Congress with claims that there are "sufficient reasons" to request the material.

Continue reading…

Rep. Greg Murphy Warns Against U.S. 'Orwellian Atmosphere' With COVID

On Friday, Rep. Greg Murphy warned that our country is developing "an Orwellian atmosphere" during an interview with Newsmax.

''I've tried to be, as a physician, very consistent through this entire process,'' said Murphy, who is also a medical doctor. ''I've said from the beginning, I don't believe mandates are the right way to do things. You know you're talking about these mask mandates; you're talking about the vaccine mandates.”

Continue reading…

Sen. Marsha Blackburn: New Mask Mandates an 'Overreach' 

Senator Marsha Blackburn roasted Nancy Pelosi and others who are calling for renewed mask mandates, stating that they "obviously are not following the science and they do not believe in the efficacy of the vaccines."

"I think it's a bit of an overreach," she told Newsmax on Friday. "You are seeing (Speaker) Nancy Pelosi try to pull another power play. Bear in mind, since last March of 2020, what have we heard from these guys.They want lockdowns. They want you to wear gloves, to mask up, to socially distance."

Continue reading…

Rep. Steve Scalise: Democrats are 'Throwing Science Out the Window'

On Friday, Rep. Steve Scalise declared that Democrats are ''throwing science out the window'' in regards to COVID and mask mandates.

''If you look at this, you know that the science is being thrown out the window a lot of times because a lot of these Democrats wanted the (COVID-related) shutdowns last year, they wanted to keep kids out of schools, and you see some of them trying to lay the groundwork for that to happen again. That can't happen again," he told Newsmax. ''The science says...

Continue reading...

Gov. DeSantis: Americans Must Never be ‘Consigned to Live in Faucian Dystopia’

Florida Governor is DONE with Dr. Fauci and the rest of Joe Biden's administration when it comes to COVID restrictions and lockdowns. He declared on Wednesday that Florida will NEVER "live in a Faucian dystopia."

“I think it’s very important that we say unequivocally no to lockdowns, no to school closures, no to restrictions and no to mandates,” DeSantis declared while speaking to the American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC).

Continue reading…

Commie Canada Proposes ‘Digital Safety Commissioner’ to Block Websites Deemed ‘Harmful’

It seems like everyday our neighbors to the north slink into communism more and more.

On Thursday, Canada's Federal government released plans to created a "Digital Safety Commissioner" who can shut down websites that they deem a "threat" to "democracy" and promote "harmful" content.

Continue reading...